John & Mary's

Nestled on 496 W Main St in Arcade, NY, John & Mary's has carved out a niche as a beloved pizza restaurant and hoagie haven. Customers rave about the generous portion sizes and the delightful flavor profiles that make each dish a standout. Highlighting their menu are the hoagies, especially the Awesome Pinter Hoagie, packed with savory steak, fried onions, and melted cheese. The Chicken Cordon Bleu Hoagie, featuring crispy chicken fingers paired with ham and Swiss, also garners high praise. Beyond hoagies, the restaurant serves a variety of satisfying dinners like Butterfly Shrimp and the fried-to-perfection Fish Fry, all perfect companions to their homestyle fries and onion rings. A standout mention is the Open Souvlaki, a crowd favorite that combines marinated chicken with a fresh Greek salad, delivering a burst of Mediterranean zest at a fantastic value. Customers appreciate the quick service and the friendly atmosphere. Guy B highlights the restaurant's superiority to typical fast-food options, while Chelsea emphasizes the reliability of their online ordering. Moreover, larger groups can feel welcomed, as Harold Meyer noted the accommodating staff during family gatherings. Overall, John & Mary's delivers a delightful dining experience, blending comfort food with stellar service, making it a must-try in the area.